What We Got Wrong, and Right, About ID Camps

After my daughter tore her ACL sophomore year and missed her junior year, our family had to relearn recruiting under pressure.

A lot of what we thought we knew about ID camps turned out to be incomplete, outdated, or just wrong for the situation we were in.

That does not mean ID camps are a scam. It means most families do not think clearly enough about why they are going, when they should go, and what problem they are trying to solve.

For us, ID camps became much more important after the injury, not less.

Here is what we got wrong, and what we got right.

What We Got Wrong

1. We thought the normal recruiting timeline was the only timeline

When your athlete gets seriously injured, the recruiting calendar suddenly feels cruel.

Junior year is supposed to be the big year. That is what every recruiting guide tells you. Then an ACL tear wipes out a season and it feels like the whole process is over.

That was one of the biggest mindset mistakes we made.

The timeline was disrupted, but it was not dead.

What changed was not the need to be seen. What changed was how she was going to be seen.

2. We overvalued the idea of being tracked and undervalued live evaluation

Before the injury, it is easy to think recruiting is mostly about long-term exposure.

Club season. Showcases. Film. Coaches following you over time. All of that matters.

But when an athlete misses a critical year, a lot of that continuity disappears.

That is where ID camps mattered more than we initially realized.

At a good ID camp, coaches are not evaluating the version of your player from eight months ago. They are evaluating the player in front of them that day.

For comeback athletes, that matters a lot.

3. We did not fully appreciate how much the right camp matters

Not every ID camp solves the same problem.

Some camps are useful because they put your athlete directly in front of a staff that could genuinely recruit them.

Some are useful because they help build confidence and sharpness again.

Some are useful because they let a player prove to herself that she is really back.

And some, honestly, are just expensive noise.

I think a lot of families, including us at times, treat ID camps like a generic box to check. They are not. The value depends on fit, timing, level, geography, and where the athlete is physically and mentally.

4. We assumed the injury would be the main thing coaches saw

This is a subtle one.

When your kid is coming off an ACL tear, you can become consumed by the injury story. You worry that every coach is going to see risk first.

What we learned is that good coaches see more than that.

Yes, they want the truth. Yes, they want clarity on health. But they also see resilience, discipline, maturity, and how a player carries herself after adversity.

That does not mean the injury is irrelevant. It means it is not the whole story unless you let it become the whole story.

What We Got Right

1. We kept putting her in real evaluation environments

Once she was ready, the most important thing was getting her back in front of coaches in person.

That is where ID camps became a lifeline.

For players who missed time, live environments can reset the conversation faster than another generic email or another old highlight clip.

She did not need sympathy. She needed opportunities to be evaluated on who she was now.

2. We treated rehab as development, not dead time

This was one of the most important lessons of the whole process.

Rehab is not just a medical bridge back to playing. If the athlete approaches it right, rehab becomes part of development.

There is physical rebuilding, obviously. But there is also patience, discipline, pain tolerance, body awareness, and mental toughness.

Those things matter in recruiting, even if they do not show up on a spreadsheet.

I really do believe the process made her a stronger player and a stronger recruit.

3. We learned that a comeback story can be a signal, not a weakness

One of the biggest fears after a major injury is that the athlete will be defined by what happened to her.

But there is another version of the story.

A player who goes through surgery, rehab, setbacks, uncertainty, and still comes back ready to compete is telling coaches something important.

Character is hard to fake. Adversity reveals it.

Good coaches know that.

4. We stopped thinking in generic recruiting advice and started thinking in specifics

This helped a lot.

Instead of asking broad questions like “Should she go to ID camps?” the better questions were:

• Which camps actually fit her level?
• Which staffs are realistic targets?
• Is she healthy enough to perform well right now?
• Is this camp helping exposure, confidence, fit, or all three?
• Is this worth the money, travel, and energy at this stage?

Recruiting got better when we stopped chasing abstract advice and started making concrete decisions.

The Biggest Lesson

If your athlete is coming back from injury, ID camps are not automatically the answer.

But they can become one of the best tools you have.

For us, they mattered because they created a fresh evaluation window.

They gave coaches a chance to see the athlete she was after the injury, after the rehab, after the lost year. Not the player they had stopped tracking. Not the kid on the sideline. The actual player in front of them.

That changed everything.

What I Would Tell Parents Now

If I could compress this into a few direct takeaways, it would be this:

• Do not assume the timeline is over because it changed
• Do not treat all ID camps as equal
• Do not send your kid just to say you went
• Do use camps strategically when your athlete is healthy and ready
• Do remember that live evaluation can reopen doors faster than you think
• Do not underestimate what adversity can reveal to the right coach

ID camps did not magically save recruiting for us.

But the right camps, at the right time, for the right reasons, helped us rebuild momentum when it felt like we had lost it.

That is a very different thing, and an important one.

---

If you are trying to figure out which camps are actually worth your time, I built IDCampFinder to make that part easier.

The hard part is the injury, the rehab, and the uncertainty. Finding the right camps should not be the hard part.